Home | Commentary | News | Forum | The Loft | Online Activist | State News | Resources | Classifieds Subscribe | Mobile | RSS | Contact

       

Printer-Friendly Version

Gun Law Dichotomy
By Jon E. Dougherty
June 15, 2005

Supporters of gun control say more gun laws are needed to protect innocent Americans by restricting their access to firearms. However, it is becoming increasingly difficult for the anti-gunners to escape the fact that the more restrictive the gun laws, the more Americans are at put at risk.

Rare is the moment you will hear the federal government admit it or see an FBI report documenting it, but I am of the opinion it is no coincidence violent crime began dropping dramatically in the 1990s, not because of the Clinton administration's ridiculous "assault" weapons ban or "community policing" programs, but because most state legislatures passed laws allowing law-abiding citizens to carry concealed weapons. It made sense; after all, criminals had been carrying them for years anyway, despite the fact that it wasn't legal to do so. What nerve.

In a bid to make you think otherwise, however, the gun-grabbing Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence offers up this "statistic:" "The number of crime victims who successfully use firearms to defend themselves is quite small. According to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports and the Centers for Disease Control, out of 30,708 Americans who died by gunfire in 1998, only 316 were shot in justifiable homicides by private citizens with firearms (Brady's emphasis)."

Putting aside the fact that the Brady bunch seems to be hinting the 316 Americans who used their own weapons for self-defense shouldn't be praised for surviving, what is this statistic supposed to prove? Without knowing the details behind the figures -- like, how many of those killed were armed as well and had a chance to fight back, or under what circumstances the attacks took place (were the victims leapt upon by surprise, for instance), and other details, it's worthless propaganda.

In fact the Brady Campaign seems to look upon CCW laws with contempt, as if law-abiding Americans shouldn't have the right to protect themselves by utilizing their constitutionally guaranteed right to bear arms.

In an atypical moment of candor the government did, in 2003, take the time to examine all manner of gun control laws, to ascertain whether they really did as advertised: reduced gun-related violent crime.

"A sweeping federal review of the nation's gun-control laws including mandatory waiting periods and bans on certain weapons found no proof such measures reduce firearm violence," The Associated Press reported, detailing the findings of a Centers for Disease Control analysis. Analysts also said "firearms-related injuries" in the U.S. declined since 1993 despite the fact that "approximately 4.5 million new firearms are sold each year."

Writing for Insight on the News, Woody West notes that "the premise of right-to-carry or "shall-issue" statutes is impeccably logical: Predators may be more circumspect if they have reason to think their intended 'victims' might have a loaded pistol in pocket or purse or, if the thugs aren't that smart, it may not be the law-abiding citizen who gets hurt."

>> Continued -- Page 1 2

       

 

++ Check out the GOPUSA home page for the latest information.

Last Updated:
Saturday 10:16 am EDT



Not a member? Click here.
Tea Parties This Weekend!! by MeaganM
Palin resigning as Alaska governor by MeaganM
Administration launches immigration crackdown by Der Alte
Palin resigning as Alaska governor by qrayjack
Discuss Issues in the Forum

Action Alerts
Action Alert: Hands Off My Health Care Decisions!

Legislation and Votes
Roll Call Vote - Cap & Trade Bill on passage
H.R. 2454 - Cap and Trade Bill
House Roll Call Vote To permit citizen defense by the carrying of loaded firearms in national parks
Roll Call Vote - Coburn Amdt. No. 1067; To protect innocent Americans from violent crime in national parks and refuges.
Roll Call Vote - Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act

Grassroots Survey Team
View recent survey results
Join the survey team!



GOPUSA Cartoons
Click here!

++ Help the RNC fight Obama and ABC News!

++ The Future of The Republican Party, tell us what YOU Think!

++ ACLU Terrified by Reprint of 140-yr-old Book