Last Updated:November 24 @ 11:47 am

Schlafly: The Hypocrisy of Amnesty Advocates

By Phyllis Schlafly

Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again but expecting different results. The Ronald Reagan amnesty of 1986 was a conspicuous failure, and a virtually identical plan failed in 2007 when it was pushed by John McCain, Ted Kennedy and George W. Bush.

Now the establishment has lined up eight senators plus a media chorus to resurrect the Reagan amnesty. That may make sense if you are seeking left-wing Democratic votes, but it is insanity for conservatives and Republicans.

The Reagan amnesty admitted twice as many illegals as expected and was riddled with fraud and cheating. It started a gigantic stream of illegal aliens to walk, swim or bribe their way across the border into the U.S., and that has continued to this day.

The amnesty pushers are counting on Americans not to remember the Reagan failure and counting on the American people's ignorance of arithmetic and politics. They are also hoping to make Republicans believe amnesty is the key to getting the Hispanic vote, plus the key to conning religious citizens into believing amnesty is the way to practice Christian compassion.

The amnesty proposal cooked up by six senators who claim to be bipartisan is essentially the same plan that aroused the fury of the grassroots in 2007 and covered congressmen with a tsunami of messages. But there is one big difference today; this time we know the cost, and that's truly scary.

Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation estimates that this amnesty plan will cost the U.S. taxpayers "$2.5 Trillion above any taxes paid in" because the majority of illegal aliens who would eventually be legalized by the proposal are uneducated and poor. At least 60 percent are high school dropouts, so they live below the poverty level and will be eligible to receive many of our 79 varieties of welfare handouts.

The entire plan should be illegal because it violates an explicit tenet of federal law that anyone granted entry into the U.S. must be financially self-supporting and not likely to become a public charge. Of course President Obama is not shy about issuing illegal executive orders.

Republican Senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama pointed out, "We know already that the administration refuses to enforce existing law restricting immigrant welfare use, and in fact promotes expanded welfare use to immigrants, including food stamps, public housing and Medicaid. ... What good are promises of future enforcement when the administration covertly undermines those laws now in place?"

There is no way that supporting amnesty will give Republicans the Hispanic vote, and amnesty advocates are plainly dishonest when they assert the contrary. In the election following the Reagan amnesty, George H.W. Bush got only 30 percent of the Hispanic vote in 1988 and only 25 percent when he ran for reelection in 1992.

We've been told that George W. Bush was well liked by the Hispanics, but he got only 35 percent of the vote when he was elected in 2000. There is no evidence that any plan can give Republicans 50 percent of the Hispanic vote.

When Hispanics are asked what issues they care most about, immigration usually ranks only fifth. Hispanics who come from countries where big government is a permanent fact of life and where the economic systems are based on bribery are unlikely prospects for the Republican message of limited government and restraints on government spending.

Any amnesty plan, no matter how it is dressed up, is a formula for more Democratic votes and the big-government, big-spending policies advocated by the Democrats.

A couple of coalitions have formed to try to convince religious groups that amnesty is a manifestation of Christian compassion. In fact, it is gross hypocrisy because it betrays the millions of immigrants who came here legally and obeyed our laws.

This was well understood by the famous advocate for the rights of Hispanic immigrants, Cesar Chavez. Long deceased, he is still such an Hispanic icon that the National Education Association (NEA), year after year, passes a resolution calling for a national holiday to honor Cesar Chavez, and it's already a state holiday in California.

Chavez was vehemently opposed to illegals coming across the Mexican border because they took jobs from legal immigrants. He ordered union members to call the Immigration and Naturalization Service and report illegals working in the fields so our government could deport them.

Chavez got his supporters to picket INS offices to demand a crackdown on illegals, and he offered staff to the INS to serve as volunteer border guards to keep Mexicans from sneaking into the U.S. Occasionally, Chavez's people even physically attacked illegals to scare them away.


Phyllis Schlafly is a lawyer, conservative political analyst and author of 20 books. She is the co-author, with George Neumayr, of the New York Times Best-Seller titled "No Higher Power: Obama's War on Religious Freedom." She can be contacted by e-mail at To find out more about Phyllis Schlafly and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Website at


VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
Rate this post:
Rating: 9.7/10 (26 votes cast)
Schlafly: The Hypocrisy of Amnesty Advocates , 9.7 out of 10 based on 26 ratings

Don't leave yet! Add a comment below or check out these other great stories:


  1. fabianComment by fabian
    February 20, 2013 @ 10:23 am

    Put the amnesty into effect and sugar coat it with $ 9 minimum wage et voila, you’re French.

    VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
    Rate this comment:
    Rating: 5.0/5 (4 votes cast)
  2. JDZComment by JDZ
    February 20, 2013 @ 10:51 am

    What is “comprehensive” immigration reform? Does anyone understand what changes this would mean to our current immigration laws and regulations? My guess is that it will be some politically correct bureaucratic reinterpretation of a form of amnesty for the millions of illegals in our country under the guise of “comprehensive immigration reform”. Also, given how incompetent our government has become, whatever they come up with will affect probably twice as many illegals then the current estimate of 12 million people as our government really has lost control of illegal crossings. Not only do we not really know how many…but we do not know where they are.

    Doesn’t this make you feel safe and so proud of our federal and state governments when it is so easy for anyone to enter our country and disappear into some illegal version of assimilation? How many of the 12 to 20 million of illegals are felons or potential terrorists? It it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see How much of a disservice our homeland security and attorney organizations have done to our country by their inability to close off our borders and deal with this massive problem. This out of control illegal immigration problem is undermining both our national security and economy and getting worse by the day and the liberals in this country are responsible for this problem, not the conservatives. The liberals are open border, illegal immigrant sympathizers for self serving political reasons under the guise of caring for the unfortunate.

    Someday the American public will realize how they have been conned by these liberal snake oil salespersons.

    VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
    Rate this comment:
    Rating: 4.4/5 (7 votes cast)
    • rzraickComment by rzraick
      February 20, 2013 @ 7:07 pm

      People who are conned are reluctant to admit their own stupidity. How else can you explain the last election?

      VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
      Rate this comment:
      Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)

Leave a Comment

  • "An excellent article. I have noticed over the past several years when I would read resumes and conduct interviews,..." Comment by Goldminer
    Posted in Who Created These Campus Whiners?
  • "Parents today tell their children over and over again how wonderful they are even for the smallest achievement. So..." Comment by Bobinms
    Posted in Who Created These Campus Whiners?
  • "True. Latest evidence? WH admin (Josh Earnest to be exact) saying the 'Republicans' are in effect thwarting efforts..." Comment by ifeelgood
    Posted in Who Created These Campus Whiners?

Network-wide options by YD - Freelance Wordpress Developer