Last Updated:May 16 @ 04:40 pm

Limbaugh: Mark Levin's 'Ameritopia'

By David Limbaugh

Mark Levin's hard work in researching, organizing and writing his new book, "Ameritopia," will be a blessing for all who read it.

Countless books chronicle the forward march of the liberal agenda and attempt to deconstruct the fallacies in modern leftist thinking. Many critique the statist policies the left has imposed on us the past half-century and their disastrous effects on our culture, our economy and our national security.

Few modern books, however, direct our attention to first principles, perhaps assuming people implicitly understand the philosophical and ideological underpinnings of conservative thinking, and even fewer truly explore the anatomy of the liberal vision.

In "Liberty and Tyranny," Levin laid out the conservative vision and contrasted it with the liberal vision. But "Ameritopia" examines more deeply the historical and philosophical roots of the utopian ideal, for it is that ideal that has always animated the liberal worldview.

Levin takes us through the seminal thoughts of some of the most noted political philosophers and writers who laid out the utopian vision -- from Plato to Thomas More, Thomas Hobbes and Karl Marx -- and then unpacks the contrasting vision of John Locke, Baron de Montesquieu and others whose ideas greatly influenced America's founders.

Liberal utopianism is a fantasy of arrogant philosophers and philosopher kings who believe their vision is superior to those of other lowly mortals. Levin calls them the "masterminds" -- the latest and most prominent being President Barack Obama and his cadre of utopian elitists. They believe they are proponents of enlightenment thinking and rationalism who could construct the ideal society if deniers and other obstructionists would just get out of their way.

In reality, however, they couldn't be more irrational, as they reject human nature, history and all empirical evidence that contradicts their vision. Indeed, writes Levin, "utopianism is regressive, irrational, and pre-Enlightenment."

History and the whole of human experience be damned; utopians can achieve the ideal society even if all similar utopians who preceded them failed. As Levin says, they always believe that "what went before them" was "piecemeal and therefore inadequate. The steps necessary to achieve true utopianism have yet to be tried."

As modern examples, consider the American left's refusal to accept that the welfare state has failed despite $5 trillion being thrown at it, that federal money and control are not a panacea for education (there will never be enough to satisfy leftists) and that our health care system has been severely damaged by federal intermeddlers and enemies of the market. The left doesn't even believe that the colossally wasteful trillion-dollar stimulus package was big enough.

As Plato argued in his "Republic," utopians believe the individual must subordinate his will to the state. They must destroy individuality and individual liberty because those stand in opposition to the conformity their utopian vision demands.

Standing in stark contrast are America's constitutional framers, who rejected the folly that certain superior representatives of the species could change the entire species' intrinsic nature. They believed in man's natural rights and cherished the individual liberty flowing from those rights. As students of history, philosophy and human nature, they refused to follow the path of utopians who rejected the realities not only of human nature but also of the evidence of its outworkings in history, especially in man's endless experiments in statecraft. With wide-eyed recognition of human nature, they crafted the American Constitution to maximize individual liberties, despite the natural tendency of man toward absolutism.

As the Constitution established that essential balance between governmental power and individual liberties by sufficiently empowering but also limiting governmental power, it is essential that its structure be maintained if our freedom is to be preserved.

Utopian leftists view the Constitution not as a structural safeguard for our liberties, but as an obstacle to their utopian goal of concentrating power in the central government to empower them to implement their grand vision. They only champion the Constitution as a matter of political expedience, when it serves their larger ends. In Levin's words: "For the mastermind, the Constitution's words are undeserving of respect as the rest of history. They will be used to muddle and disarrange, not inform and clarify."

The left has succeeded in dismantling much of the American freedom tradition -- through legislative, executive and judicial assaults on the Constitution -- all in the name of advancing a seductive form of equality that denies and seeks to neutralize human nature and leaves tyranny in its wake.

We are in a war for the survival of the republic, and no modern writer has better articulated what is at stake or laid out with such accessible clarity the competing visions and their respective consequences for America.

---

David Limbaugh is a writer, author and attorney. His latest book, "Crimes Against Liberty," was No. 1 on the New York Times best-seller list for nonfiction for its first two weeks. Follow him on Twitter @davidlimbaugh and his website at www.davidlimbaugh.com.

COPYRIGHT 2012 CREATORS.COM

VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
Rate this post:
Rating: 10.0/10 (9 votes cast)
Limbaugh: Mark Levin's 'Ameritopia', 10.0 out of 10 based on 9 ratings
Don't leave yet! Add a comment below or check out these other great stories:

4 Comments

  1. DaveComment by Dave
    January 17, 2012 @ 9:48 am

    While this is certainly a pitch for a product, it also speaks to the truth of what is occurring in America today. The truth cannot be ignored.

    VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
    Rate this comment:
    Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)
  2. newsjunkyComment by newsjunky
    January 17, 2012 @ 10:04 am

    Everyone is writing books these days, and many books seem to be on the same topic, the decline of America, and the reasons for that decline.  Although, I’ve read some of these books and consider them to be very informative and educational – I just wish that all that knowledge and know-how could be put to better use actively in these critical times.

    If all these exceptional people with extraordinary minds could come together for the betterment of this country we might stand a chance against the liberal masses before we’re at a point in time when writing books against the government and those in power is prohibited.

    VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
    Rate this comment:
    Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
    • inluminatuoComment by inluminatuo
      January 17, 2012 @ 10:17 am

      Exceptional people with extaordinary minds are the very thing that the secular Liberals fear, because it is in their truth that the socialist lies are exposed and the failure of their ideology revealed. Why else do they seek to control our educational systems to keep our potential leaders of exception from growing to full fruition to challenge their deceptions. This would threaten their phony manufactured socialist Utopia and reveal it for the fraud that it is, and result in their loss of power over the uninformed American minds.

      Mark Levine’s exceptional book is a must read by those in pursuit of exceptional minds before anyone casts their next unexceptional ballot.

      VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
      Rate this comment:
      Rating: 5.0/5 (3 votes cast)
  3. inluminatuoComment by inluminatuo
    January 17, 2012 @ 10:13 am

     
    Our American founders understood the laws of nature and the synergistic power of the free individual in his free unencumbered pursuit of happiness to create a whole which become so much greater than the sum of its individual parts. The Socialist dreamers of the liberal nirvana and manipulated Utopia of manufactured equality of some over the actual superiority of others, only succeed in stifling the creative superior and the expense of risk taking which is designed to result in growth and improvement of society. They in their deluded socialist pre-determination of outcomes designed by the few, the proud oppressors of their deluded Utopias only result in stagnation in their obsessive pursuit of forced unnatural equality where the outcomes only degenerate to the lowest common denominator of those who hide in fear within the false security net of their failed socialist collectives.
     
    Free people only subordinate their will to a state worthy of trust to only do collectively for the people, that which they are too weak to do properly as individuals. When the state attempts to accomplish collectively that which individuals are designed to do individually, like feed and house themselves, then all the state accomplishes is breeding a race of men less human than that for which their creator originally designed them and blesses them with a free will to become.
     
    The worthy state frees men up from the fear from without so they can devote themselves to the improvement of the individual’s strength to grow strong men and a stronger society. The unworthy state enslaves individuals in their fear to dare to acquire and accomplish on their own the human qualities that enable them to live without fear or dependency as free men without fear. Unfortunately all the Liberal Democrat party of Utopian manipulators has to offer is fear itself, and the accompanying dependency decline of society that follows the decline of the individual as night follows day, as we follow Obama, Reid and Pelosi in their distorted socialist view of life which refute the very laws of nature itself.
     

    VN:F [1.9.6_1107]
    Rate this comment:
    Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)

Leave a Comment

  • "Constitutional Conventions can be, ah, big in total changes. The Constitutional Convention, to Amend the Articles of Confederation,..." Comment by lwesson
    Posted in Williams: Should We Obey All Laws?
  • "Thank you, I guess, Sir. <--- Col. Saunders accent. Lincoln's refocusing, was a desperation, two fold, and effective, ultimately in one..." Comment by lwesson
    Posted in Williams: Should We Obey All Laws?
  • "Walter Williams is one of my heroes, and his assertion that legality does not equal morality is correct. Unfortunately,..." Comment by techwreck
    Posted in Williams: Should We Obey All Laws?

Network-wide options by YD - Freelance Wordpress Developer